Websites and social networks: Difference between revisions

Corrected section relating to Wikipedia, and minor fixes otherwise
imported>Armorica Online
(Changed Facebook working to be less aggressive, but still presenting information)
imported>Armorica Online
(Corrected section relating to Wikipedia, and minor fixes otherwise)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Incomplete}}
{{Incomplete}}
[[Websites and social networks]] that do or don't give [[recognition]] to [[nonbinary]] [[gender identity]] in their user forms. For nonbinary people, the most undesirable sites are those that require all users to mark their [[gender]] as either "[[female]]" or "[[male]]," with no other options. Similarly bad are sites that mark this choice as "[[sex]]" rather than "[[gender]]". Sites that are more friendly to nonbinary people are those that let users write in their own gender, give a wide variety of gender options to choose from a drop-down menu, give a third gender option such as "[[other]]", or don't ask about gender at all. Some sites also ask about a user's [[gender neutral titles|title]] or [[pronouns]], and ideally let users include more than the standard [[binary genders|binary]] options for these.
The following is a list of '''websites and social networks''' and their [[recognition]] of [[nonbinary]] [[gender identity]] in their user forms. For many nonbinary people, the most undesirable sites are those which require all users to mark their [[gender]] as either "[[female]]" or "[[male]]" with no other options. Similarly bad are sites that mark this choice as "[[sex]]" rather than "[[gender]]". Sites that are more friendly to nonbinary people include those which allow users write in their own gender, provide a wide variety of gender options to choose from within a drop-down menu, give a third gender option such as "[[other]]", or don't ask about gender at all. Some sites also ask about a user's [[gender neutral titles|title]] or [[pronouns]], and ideally let users include more than the standard [[binary genders|binary]] options for these.


==How to use this page==
==How to use this page==
Please add to the entries on this page.


For easy skimming, the tables on this page use a colour code, loosely based on traffic lights, to show how friendly a site is to nonbinary people:
For easy skimming, the tables on this page use a colour code, loosely based on traffic lights, to show how friendly a site is to nonbinary people:


* blue (#9ff) means it's friendly to nonbinary people. For example, you can write in your gender (even blank it) or opt out of showing it.
* Blue (#9ff) means it's friendly to nonbinary people. For example, you can write in your gender (even blank it) or opt out of showing it.
* Green (#9f9) means it does not ask.
* Green (#9f9) means it does not ask.
* yellow (#ffb) means it's partly friendly to nonbinary people. For example, users must choose between showing a gender that is female, male, or other.
* Yellow (#ffb) means it's partly friendly to nonbinary people. For example, users must choose between showing a gender that is female, male, or other.
* red (#f99) means it's not friendly at all to nonbinary people. For example, it may require all users to be openly listed as male or female.
* Red (#f99) means it's not friendly at all to nonbinary people. For example, it may require all users to be openly listed as male or female.
* white background means we don't have information about this yet, or some other situation (describe)
A white background means we don't have information about this site yet, or that there is some other situation (these situations should be described when possible).


If you want to quickly create an entry for a site, but you don't want to tangle with the tables, please use this as a template for writing a draft of an entry in list form instead, which you can put on the Talk page, and an administrator will put it into the table for you:
If you want to quickly create an entry for a site but don't want to tangle with the tables, use the list below as a template for writing a draft of an entry in list form instead. This can then be put on [[Talk:Websites and social networks|the talk page]], and an administrator will add it into the table for you.


: '''Site name,''' web address, and purpose.
: '''Site name,''' web address, and purpose.
Line 59: Line 57:
|-
|-
| [http://www.deviantart.com/ DeviantArt]. Art community.
| [http://www.deviantart.com/ DeviantArt]. Art community.
| style="background-color:#ffb;" |<s>Calls this field "Sex." The user is required to choose from one of the three sex options given in the drop-down menu, which allows ‘Other’. Another drop-down menu allows the user to show or not show their sex selection on their profile. [http://nonbinary.org/wiki/File:DeviantArt_profile_evidence.jpg Evidence, 2015].</s>
| style="background-color:#ffb;" |As of the ''Eclipse'' update (circa 2020), the website requires neither the gender nor sex of users, only requiring their pronouns instead. The only pronouns available however are "he", "she" and "they".
As of the Eclipse update (Circa 2020), the website no longer demands the gender nor sex of the person, but rather it asks for the person's pronouns. Only "He", "She" and "They" are currently available.
Previously, the site required a user to input their sex from a drop down menu of three options, those being "male", "female", and "other". Within another menu however the choice was given as to whether or not their selection of sex was shown on their profile. [http://nonbinary.org/wiki/File:DeviantArt_profile_evidence.jpg Evidence, 2015].
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No. The user profile has a field called "real name," but the user can put any name into it they want. Legal names are neither enforced nor commonly used on the site.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No. The user profile has a field called "real name," but the user can submit anything into it. Legal names are neither enforced nor commonly used on the site.
| No title field. The site has history of administrators saying transphobic things to users. 'Other' as an option was once available, but taken away sometime prior to 2011. After a [[neutrois]] user was told to leave the site if [[pronouns#It|it]] "did not wish to state [its] gender", and the administrators told [[pronouns#it|it]] the field was about a user's genital sex and not gender identity, the backlash caused DeviantArt's administrators to backpedal and re-add "Other" as an option in late 2011.
| No title field.
Previously DeviantArt required users to input their sex, with "other" being an option, but this was removed sometime prior to 2011. A [[neutrois]] user was told to leave the site if [[pronouns#It|it]] "did not wish to state [its] gender", with administrators stating that the field was about users' genital sex and not gender identity. This action lead to backlash from the community, causing DeviantArt to re-add "other" as an option in late-2011.
|-
|-
|[https://joindiaspora.com/ DIASPORA]. Social network.
|[https://joindiaspora.com/ DIASPORA]. Social network.
Line 125: Line 124:
|-
|-
|[http://habitrpg.com HabitRPG]. Time management made into a multiplayer game.
|[http://habitrpg.com HabitRPG]. Time management made into a multiplayer game.
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |No field. No way to enter your gender at all. Your game avatar is genderless. You can choose between two body types for your game avatar, called "slim" and "broad," but they're both gender-neutral figures. You can dress your game avatar in any combination of hairstyles, facial hair, or clothing you want, and none of these things are marked as being for one gender only.
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |No field and no way to enter your gender at all; your game avatar being genderless. You can choose between two body types for your game avatar, called "slim" and "broad," but they're both gender-neutral figures. You can dress your game avatar in any combination of hairstyles, facial hair, and clothing desired, with none of them marked or categorized in a binary way.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No
|
|
|-
|-
|[https://www.instagram.com/ Instagram]. Image posting social network.
|[https://www.instagram.com/ Instagram]. Image posting social network.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |Gender can be male, female, custom, or "prefer not to say". Or you can just avoid selecting any of the options. Starting May 2021, a pronoun field in the profile was implemented; users can add up to four pronouns from a pre-approved list.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |Gender can be set as male, female, custom, or "prefer not to say", although one can avoid selecting any of the options. Starting May 2021, a pronoun field in the profile was implemented; users can add up to four pronouns from a pre-approved list.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |You can use "either your full name, nickname, or business name", and can change it twice every 14 days.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |You can use "either your full name, nickname, or business name", and can change it twice every 14 days.
|
|
Line 235: Line 234:
|
|
|-
|-
|[http://www.wikipedia.org/ Wikipedia]. Free encyclopedia Wiki.
|[http://www.wikipedia.org/ Wikipedia]. Free online encyclopedia.
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |If the user is a Wikipedia contributor, they can put [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Userboxes, Userboxes] on the profile, which allow for a great deal of gender, sex, and orientation description. See also [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:ISD/Userboxes/Sexuality#Gender_identity, User:ISD/Userboxes/Sexuality]. Some of the userboxes that have been made with English descriptions, many with images, include: [[femme]], [[boi]], [[two-spirit]], [[kathoey]], [[hijra]], [[transgender]], [[transsexual]], [[genderqueer]], [[androgyny|androgynous]], [[intersexual]], [[bigender]], [[trigender]], [[pangender]], [[third gender]], “This user has no gender identity, nor a sexual orientation,and “This user is still unsure about their gender identity.
| style="background-color:#ffb;" |Does not require users to submit their gender or pronouns when creating an account. The site refers to all users using they/them pronouns by default, with the only options being "gender neutral", "feminine", and "masculine".
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No
| style="background-color:#9ff;" |No
|
|If one creates an account on Wikipedia, a variety of user-created [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Userboxes userboxes] are available to be placed on one's user page. Out of already existing userboxes, many different options are available for users to describe their gender identity, pronouns, and orientation, among other topics.
|-
|-
|[http://youtube.com YouTube]. Video community.
|[http://youtube.com YouTube]. Video community.
Line 272: Line 271:
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |Doesn't ask about gender or sex.
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |Doesn't ask about gender or sex.
|
|
|They let you type your own title into the text field so you can put Mx or anything else you like. [http://mxactivist.tumblr.com/post/40851665833 Evidence, January 2013.]
|Allows user input of any title into a text field.
[http://mxactivist.tumblr.com/post/40851665833 Evidence, January 2013.]
|-  
|-  
|[https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/irl-lets-hang/id1332596741?mt=8 IRL - Let's Hang] (iOS app)
|[https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/irl-lets-hang/id1332596741?mt=8 IRL - Let's Hang] (iOS app)
Line 282: Line 282:
| style="background-color:#ffb;" | Users can enter their "Sex" as Unknown, Male, or Female. Text in games refers to everyone as "they/them/their" regardless which sex you enter.
| style="background-color:#ffb;" | Users can enter their "Sex" as Unknown, Male, or Female. Text in games refers to everyone as "they/them/their" regardless which sex you enter.
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |Does not ask about legal name.
| style="background-color:#9f9;" |Does not ask about legal name.
|Site will shut down after 2020 due to Flash support ending.
|
|-
|-
|[https://www.twitch.tv Twitch], streaming entertainment platform
|[https://www.twitch.tv Twitch], streaming entertainment platform