Talk:Emasculation: Difference between revisions

    From Nonbinary Wiki
    imported>MorningSparrow
    (discussion on deletion/change)
     
    imported>MorningSparrow
     
    (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
    Line 1: Line 1:
    ==Possible deletion or changing==
    ==Possible deletion or changing==
    This term seems to be outdated, and the page doesn't talk about emasculation as a concept. I propose either deleting the page, changing it to reflect it being outdated, or changing the page to reflect emasculation as a concept. We could also make a disambiguation page for emasculation. [[User:MorningSparrow|MorningSparrow]] ([[User talk:MorningSparrow|talk]]) 01:12, 15 April 2019 (UTC)
    This term seems to be outdated, and the page doesn't talk about emasculation as a concept. I propose either deleting the page, changing it to reflect it being outdated, or changing the page to reflect emasculation as a concept. We could also make a disambiguation page for emasculation. [[User:MorningSparrow|MorningSparrow]] ([[User talk:MorningSparrow|talk]]) 01:12, 15 April 2019 (UTC)
    : Is there a different term for the surgical procedure of penectomy-with-orchiectomy than emasculation that has become more popular? If not, I believe the article should keep its current title. I believe it's better for this content to have its own article, so that the main article about bottom surgery stays more like a list of types of surgeries, and doesn't get too detailed about any particular procedure. I believe emasculation-as-a-concept is not particularly relevant to this wiki, and therefore doesn't have a place in this article. However, emasculation-as-a-surgical-procedure is absolutely on-topic for this wiki's resources about physical transition. -[[User:Sekhet|Sekhet]] ([[User talk:Sekhet|talk]]) 03:20, 15 April 2019 (UTC)
    :: The term for both a penectomy and an orchiectomy is simply a penecotmy if I recall correctly. However even without direct confirmation I think there must be a better phrase, somewhere, because the term "emasculation" simply is not a good one to use in a trans context. If I can, I will provide alternatives/sources at a later date. [[User:MorningSparrow|MorningSparrow]] ([[User talk:MorningSparrow|talk]]) 05:28, 15 April 2019 (UTC)

    Latest revision as of 05:29, 15 April 2019

    Possible deletion or changing[edit source]

    This term seems to be outdated, and the page doesn't talk about emasculation as a concept. I propose either deleting the page, changing it to reflect it being outdated, or changing the page to reflect emasculation as a concept. We could also make a disambiguation page for emasculation. MorningSparrow (talk) 01:12, 15 April 2019 (UTC)

    Is there a different term for the surgical procedure of penectomy-with-orchiectomy than emasculation that has become more popular? If not, I believe the article should keep its current title. I believe it's better for this content to have its own article, so that the main article about bottom surgery stays more like a list of types of surgeries, and doesn't get too detailed about any particular procedure. I believe emasculation-as-a-concept is not particularly relevant to this wiki, and therefore doesn't have a place in this article. However, emasculation-as-a-surgical-procedure is absolutely on-topic for this wiki's resources about physical transition. -Sekhet (talk) 03:20, 15 April 2019 (UTC)
    The term for both a penectomy and an orchiectomy is simply a penecotmy if I recall correctly. However even without direct confirmation I think there must be a better phrase, somewhere, because the term "emasculation" simply is not a good one to use in a trans context. If I can, I will provide alternatives/sources at a later date. MorningSparrow (talk) 05:28, 15 April 2019 (UTC)