User talk:Sekhet: Difference between revisions
→Cyan and other neutral names
(→Cyan and other neutral names: new section) |
imported>Sekhet |
||
| Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
Hi! Someone in the Discord server brought up that ''Cyan'' is missing from the neutral names list and it was removed with [https://nonbinary.wiki/w/index.php?title=Neutral_names_starting_with_C&type=revision&diff=24654&oldid=24215&diffmode=source this edit]. I remember you were working on these lists, so maybe we already talked about this, but I'm confused as to why this (and other names) were removed although they had a source that marked them as neutral/unisex/male & female. Let me know your thoughts! ^^ --[[User:Ondo|Ondo]] ([[User talk:Ondo|talk]]) 17:53, 23 April 2021 (UTC) | Hi! Someone in the Discord server brought up that ''Cyan'' is missing from the neutral names list and it was removed with [https://nonbinary.wiki/w/index.php?title=Neutral_names_starting_with_C&type=revision&diff=24654&oldid=24215&diffmode=source this edit]. I remember you were working on these lists, so maybe we already talked about this, but I'm confused as to why this (and other names) were removed although they had a source that marked them as neutral/unisex/male & female. Let me know your thoughts! ^^ --[[User:Ondo|Ondo]] ([[User talk:Ondo|talk]]) 17:53, 23 April 2021 (UTC) | ||
: Thanks for asking about this. I've been thinking I should write about my emerging methodology for this project. Originally, I used to include every neutral name I could find, because I wanted it to be comprehensive. Then the name list got so long that I couldn't see how I could complete the project, and I was finding that it included a lot of names that sources said were neutral names, but which turned out not to be really used as neutral names. Lately, I've been instead limiting the scope of the name lists by only including those names where I can find statistics or other evidence showing that they have been used as neutral names, whether currently, or historically. I've been removing names if the statistics show they are used as feminine 90% of the time or more, or masculine 90% of the time or more (unless if there is evidence that the names used to be more neutral at a different point in history), or where I could not find statistics proving the name's gender distribution really is neutral, even though there are sources saying they are neutral names. (Cyan was one of the names where I did not find gender distribution stats about it, only sources claiming that it was neutral.) Limiting the scope like this helps make the project more manageable in size, and makes it so we can be sure that the names really are used as neutral names. On the other hand, sometimes I feel disappointed about having to omit a lot of wonderful names just because I couldn't find evidence that satisfied my rules for what to include. --[[User:Sekhet|Sekhet]] ([[User talk:Sekhet|talk]]) 00:11, 17 May 2021 (UTC) | |||