Singular they: Difference between revisions

    From Nonbinary Wiki
    m (1 revision imported: import from nonbinary.wiki)
    (Traditional grammar, and therefore grammarians, have chosen gender of pronouns to match the sex (which is physical) of the person rather than the gender (which is psychological and a matter of self-identification). So 'sex' is more accurate here.)
    Line 2: Line 2:


    == Grammatical concerns ==
    == Grammatical concerns ==
    Grammarians question and debate the validity of also using this set as "singular they," a gender-neutral pronoun for an individual whose gender isn't specified, because they feel unsatisfied by how it still works grammatically like a plural. (Similar to how we say "you are," even when referring to a singular "you.") However, "singular they" has been common usage in English for over a thousand years, as attested by many written documents. It was used so by Shakespeare, Jane Austen, the Oxford English Dictionary, Louis Carroll, C. S. Lewis, and others. Grammaticians only recently decided that it was ungrammatical to use in the singular, because it is still used with verbs as though it was a plural.<ref>Henry Churchyard, "Singular 'Their' in Jane Austen and Elsewhere." http://www.crossmyt.com/hc/linghebr/austheir.html</ref> Though the grammar may be questionable, it is still standard use today.
    Grammarians question and debate the validity of also using this set as "singular they," a gender-neutral pronoun for an individual whose sex isn't specified, because they feel unsatisfied by how it still works grammatically like a plural. (Similar to how we say "you are," even when referring to a singular "you.") However, "singular they" has been common usage in English for over a thousand years, as attested by many written documents. It was used so by Shakespeare, Jane Austen, the Oxford English Dictionary, Louis Carroll, C. S. Lewis, and others. Grammaticians only recently decided that it was ungrammatical to use in the singular, because it is still used with verbs as though it was a plural.<ref>Henry Churchyard, "Singular 'Their' in Jane Austen and Elsewhere." http://www.crossmyt.com/hc/linghebr/austheir.html</ref> Though the grammar may be questionable, it is still standard use today.


    Singular "they" gets a surprising number of complaints, considering people use it all the time for people whose gender is unknown. However, there are a lot of arguments that it's correct. [http://motivatedgrammar.wordpress.com/2009/09/10/singular-they-and-the-many-reasons-why-its-correct/ This article on Motivated Grammar] goes through a few reasons, including the fact that it's consistently been in use since Chaucer's time, around 1400. Most people are familiar with how singular "they" works, as plenty of people use it all the time without really thinking about it.
    Singular "they" gets a surprising number of complaints, considering people use it all the time for people whose gender is unknown. However, there are a lot of arguments that it's correct. [http://motivatedgrammar.wordpress.com/2009/09/10/singular-they-and-the-many-reasons-why-its-correct/ This article on Motivated Grammar] goes through a few reasons, including the fact that it's consistently been in use since Chaucer's time, around 1400. Most people are familiar with how singular "they" works, as plenty of people use it all the time without really thinking about it.

    Revision as of 15:02, 3 December 2017

    Singular they is the standard English gender neutral pronoun for any individual whose gender is unknown or unspecified. For this reason, "they" pronouns are one of the three most popular pronouns used for real nonbinary people, as shown in surveys (see below).

    Grammatical concerns

    Grammarians question and debate the validity of also using this set as "singular they," a gender-neutral pronoun for an individual whose sex isn't specified, because they feel unsatisfied by how it still works grammatically like a plural. (Similar to how we say "you are," even when referring to a singular "you.") However, "singular they" has been common usage in English for over a thousand years, as attested by many written documents. It was used so by Shakespeare, Jane Austen, the Oxford English Dictionary, Louis Carroll, C. S. Lewis, and others. Grammaticians only recently decided that it was ungrammatical to use in the singular, because it is still used with verbs as though it was a plural.[1] Though the grammar may be questionable, it is still standard use today.

    Singular "they" gets a surprising number of complaints, considering people use it all the time for people whose gender is unknown. However, there are a lot of arguments that it's correct. This article on Motivated Grammar goes through a few reasons, including the fact that it's consistently been in use since Chaucer's time, around 1400. Most people are familiar with how singular "they" works, as plenty of people use it all the time without really thinking about it.

    A most comprehensive article about the history of singular "they" is Henry Churchyard's web-page, Singular 'Their' in Jane Austen and Elsewhere.

    Forms

    The forms of "singular they" are they, them, their, theirs, themselves (themself, theirself, theirselves).

    • Nominative: When I tell someone a joke they laugh.
    • Accusative: When I greet a friend I hug them.
    • Pronominal possessive: When someone does not get a haircut, their hair grows long.
    • Predicative possessive: If I need a phone, my friend lets me borrow theirs.
    • Reflexive: Each child feeds themself. Or: each child feeds theirself. Or: each child feeds theirselves. Or: each child feeds themselves. (See below for information on how this form's standard use varies by dialect.)

    On Pronoun Island: http://pronoun.is/they On Pronouny: http://pronouny.xyz/pronouns/593c1223975dfa1000d4ec86

    Reflexive form variants

    There are several versions of the reflexive form of this pronoun: "themself," "theirself," "theirselves," and "themselves."

    • Themself. The Oxford Dictionary says that "themself" has been used since the 14th century for a person of unknown sex.[2]
    • Theirself, theirselves. Dictionary.com says that "theirself" has also been used for this since about 1300.[3] The Free Dictionary adds that "theirself" and "theirselves" are more common in southern and midland US English.[4]

    Because both "themself" and "theirself" are for talking about a single person, they're both considered non-standard or informal usage, despite the hundreds of years of common usage. The plural form of "themselves" is supposed to be more formal, but can sound strange when used for a single person, because they are not several "selves," but one "self". This is another part of the plural/singular "they" problem.

    People differ about which version of the reflexive form they prefer. If someone asks to be called by "they" pronouns, it might be a good idea to ask which form of the reflexive form they prefer.

    Singular they in use in fiction for nonbinary characters

    • In a short sci-fi story by Benjanun Sriduangkaew, "Silent Bridge, Pale Cascade" (2013), one of the characters is described as a "neutrois," and called by "they" pronouns.[5][6]
    • In Kameron Hurley's fantasy novel, Empire Ascendant, all people in a consent culture get to choose which of the five gender roles they identify with. Hurley calls characters who are "ungendered" by singular they pronouns.[7]
    • In K. A. Cook's anthology Crooked Words, the character Chris asks to be called by "they" pronouns. Chris is in the short stories "Blue Paint, Chocolate and Other Similes" and "Everything In A Name."[8]

    Singular they in use for real nonbinary people

    • Some notable nonbinary people who ask to be called by "singular they" pronouns include writer Ivan E. Coyote, actor Tom Phelan, actor Jiz Lee, singer-songwriter Rae Spoon, and rapper Raeen Roes.
    • Deborah Rogers mentions having a trans male student who asked to be called by "they" pronouns.[9]
    • In the 2015 Nonbinary Stats survey, "singular they" was the most popular pronoun: 74% of the nonbinary respondents asked to be called by "they" (2159 out of 2901 responses).[10]
    • In the 2016 Nonbinary Stats survey, "singular they" got the highest number of people happy for others to refer to them using "they", 77%.[11]

    See also

    External links

    References

    1. Henry Churchyard, "Singular 'Their' in Jane Austen and Elsewhere." http://www.crossmyt.com/hc/linghebr/austheir.html
    2. "Themself." Oxford Dictionaries. https://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/themself
    3. "Theirself." Dictionary.com. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/theirself
    4. "Theirselves." The Free Dictionary. http://www.thefreedictionary.com/theirself
    5. Alex Dally MacFarlane, "Post-Binary Gender in SF: ExcitoTech and Non-Binary Pronouns." June 3, 2014. Tor. http://www.tor.com/blogs/2014/06/post-binary-gender-in-sf-excitotech-and-non-binary-pronouns
    6. Benjanun Sriduangkaew, "Silent Bridge, Pale Cascade." Clarkesworld Magazine. 2013. http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/sriduangkaew_12_13/
    7. Kameron Hurley, "Beyond He-Man and She-Ra: Writing nonbinary characters." https://intellectusspeculativus.wordpress.com/2014/09/03/guest-post-beyond-he-man-she-ra-writing-non-binary-characters-by-kameron-hurley/
    8. K. A. Cook, Crooked Words. Unpaged.
    9. Deborah Rogers, "'They' has arrived at the pronoun party." December 4, 2014. Times Higher Education. http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/comment/opinion/they-has-arrived-at-the-pronoun-party/2017278.article#.VIHr5bJE0lk.facebook
    10. cassolotl, "Nonbinary Stats 2015 (worldwide) - the results." February 20, 2015. http://cassolotl.tumblr.com/post/111585517125
    11. cassolotl (Nonbinary Stats), "NB/GQ Survey 2016 - the worldwide results." March 2016. http://nonbinarystats.tumblr.com/post/141311159050/nbgq-survey-2016-the-worldwide-results
    VisualEditor - Icon - Advanced - white.svg This page, licensed as CC-BY-SA 4.0, has been imported from the old nonbinary.wiki using the same or a compatible license. It is part of nonbinary.wiki's import of the original Nonbinary Wiki and is licensed under CC BY 3.0.